BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog
No New Messages
this is opensource progekt like bluefrog - http://www.okopipi.org/
_____________________________
LINUX CLUSTER EMAIL HARVESTOR FOR SALE
Date 5/28/2006 4:26:15 AM
etherbot
Posts: 16
Joined: 8/11/2005
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to p_boss)
No New Messages
Interesting. Yet, here's a link I found on their beta site. Shows a proposed topology. Even in a P2P environment, the central framework can still be targeted with some effort. I'll certainly keep an eye on their developments.
For those interested:
http://wiki.okopipi.org/w/images/0/03/Frognet.gif
Hmmm...after reading their blogs, it would be fun to join their development team and have some fun with back dooring their framework perhaps?
Wouldn't this be a cool bnet?
< Message edited by etherbot -- 5/28/2006 6:11:36 AM >
Date 5/28/2006 5:55:05 AM
mcproxy
Posts: 42
Joined: 8/10/2005
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to p_boss)
No New Messages
I cannot for the life of me think of any way this will work. The ways they're talking about(or were initially) is like X number of people must approve the attack blah blah blah, but this is too easily infiltrated by botnets, and they know it. Anyone know how they're supposedly gonna proof vs. this?
_____________________________
--------------------------------------------------------------------
I've been around for a bit here, and am looking for invites to new boards. If anyone could spare me one, PM me. I'd be more than grateful.
Date 5/28/2006 9:35:09 AM
Mr.Green
Posts: 12
Joined: 11/14/2005
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to p_boss)
No New Messages
P2P technology is very complex, it COULD work theoretically if done in the right way.
but
1. I doubt these guys will have enough $ to develope and market it (a few mil dollars).
2. I dont see how they can make money to get a return on their investment.
Date 5/29/2006 10:42:54 AM
mcproxy
Posts: 42
Joined: 8/10/2005
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to Mr.Green)
No New Messages
quote:
ORIGINAL: Mr.Green
P2P technology is very complex, it COULD work theoretically if done in the right way.
but
1. I doubt these guys will have enough $ to develope and market it (a few mil dollars).
2. I dont see how they can make money to get a return on their investment.
I read around some of their message boards. A couple people seemed to say that the desire to get $ out of it led to the downfall. They're not gonna be looking at this too hard.
I definitely agree with your point about marketing though.
_____________________________
--------------------------------------------------------------------
I've been around for a bit here, and am looking for invites to new boards. If anyone could spare me one, PM me. I'd be more than grateful.
Date 5/29/2006 12:23:11 PM
SPAMTHEFROG
Posts: 14
Joined: 5/4/2006
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to p_boss)
No New Messages
i agree with the last two posters.
we can just relax...
even if they don't fail keeping developing the new frog at a point that it remotely works... (and i am sure they will fail - simply because what they are planning is way too complex). even if they dont, they will face many problems.
i read that they will distribute the frog in p2p channels like bittorrent, download sites etc... whats there to stop us rewriting their distributions and distribute our own versions of new frog?
they will need at least 1m users for this to pose any threat... simply because 500 p2p users are at least twice less effective than centrally controlled bnet. it wil not be simple to grow that big without marketing money.
then crucial element to success is to keep new registrations going at such a pace that it outpaces the speed of old members uninstalling the app for some reason...
also, if you look at their admin infrastructure, you will see that there will be independant admins, i.e. admins of subnets that will 'approve' DDoSes... it looks like that will further decrease the effectiveness.
and they try to make it legal... 1 optout per spam. that will require millions of frogs to pose a threat...
but honestly, i reckon they will be fed up with the project way sooner than any of the above becomes an issue. and the reason - they made the project way too complex to develop. even 20 fanatical coding antis can't pull it off.
Date 5/31/2006 3:25:29 PM
Crazy
Posts: 248
Joined: 12/17/2003
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to SPAMTHEFROG)
No New Messages
I agree with SPAMTHEFROG.
These groups are running off the Blue Frog adrenaline, which they foolishly placed their trust in. The only thing motivating this at the moment was the partial impact BlueSecurity had on the community, plus the fact that they think since the reaction was so strong from spammers, that it truely is an effective method.
By reading these discussions, I'll bet that the project will be in "discussion phases" for atleast 7 to 12 months from today... and the actual implementation and launch of this project? Really depends on the competency of their programming team and whether they can trick some sucker company to loan them a few million.
Date 6/1/2006 3:42:22 AM
SPAMTHEFROG
Posts: 14
Joined: 5/4/2006
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to p_boss)
No New Messages
One of the russian spammers behind BS campaign has done a little of research on Nathan Clayton (the okopipi guy running the show now).
Here is Nathan's digg profile:
http://digg.com/users/LaCamiseta/profile
Notice his nick there is "LaCamiseta". Its spanish for T-Shirt... Also, Camiseta is name for a fish species "Abudefduf saxatilis", according to FishBase this species feeds on spinner dolphins’ feces and vomits. LoL
His blog: http://www.claytondevelopment.com/
"About Me
I’m currently a student at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas in the fields of Linguistics and German. I should be graduating with a dual-baccalaureate in May. I’ve been using a computer since before I could ride a bike (literally!). Aside from long walks on beaches and candle-lit dinners, I enjoy working on websites, translating literature, reading, and in general being a nerd."
Edited out some of the contact info - one of those emails isn't even associated with me - Nathan
Attached is his ugly face. Oh, Nathan, what's that in the bottle? The feces or the vomit? LOL
Frogs are now monitoring our conversations here
I like how they call us "just script kiddies with lotsa money". and that "The *REAL* danger guys, is the Lex Luthor (I'm talking about Pharma') who's hiding in some secret lab, studying our papers and data... "
PharmaMaster LoL.
I wish all frog community a best of luck in launching their 2nd baby, cuz the spammers need to fill that void that appeared after BS got shut down. Many spammers need a sense of purpose, making money for the sake of money is boring. Fucking with frogs was fun... keep'em comming.
stf
Attachment (1)
< Message edited by SPAMTHEFROG -- 6/3/2006 3:53:10 AM >
Date 6/3/2006 3:49:06 AM
SteveWhite
Posts: 26
Joined: 11/14/2005
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to p_boss)
No New Messages
its black frog guys, probably the lazy cousin of bluefrog who has been oppressed for 100 years who would rather eat chicken than stop spam.
Date 6/3/2006 4:20:56 PM
ebulker
Posts: 240
Joined: 7/6/2005
RE: BlackFrog NEW EDITION of BlueFrog (in reply to p_boss)
No New Messages
now spam industry is even stronger than it was. noone can stop, they can just filter part of us. it works only if they change internet globally.
_____________________________
Here is what you're looking for:
http://bulker.biz
icq# 333192431
Right and easy way to make BIG money!
Date 6/5/2006 9:20:40 AM
Page: [1]
All Forums >>SpecialHam >>Blah...Blah...Blah... >> Page: [1]
Jump to:
Advertise | Support Us | Contact Us | Sitemap | Copyright © 2003-2004 SpecialHam.com
Comments
Hope you don't mind
But I did a quick edit of just a few lines in that blog entry - I cut out the emails and some of my IM accounts. I'm not even associated with one of those email addresses.
As far as I know, it has not
As far as I know, it has not started solely due to the whitepaper for the P2P/Okopipi design is being written still.
You're right
The whitepaper is still being written, Nano's been out on business for the past couple of weeks with little to no free time. Nothing much will be happening over the next week or so at least. It's a national holiday here stateside, one of the core just got back from an extended vacation, and another will be moving shortly, so we're kind of held up right now.
Just so you know, we are sending out a sort of questionnaire to all of the people who've signed up on the wiki as being willing to volunteer as coders in preparation for this. If you're willing and don't want to be assicaiated with that, just go ahead and contact me privately and I can forward it on to the appropriate people.
We've also got another side project in the works which'll be working hand-in-hand with the Okopipi project. More on that when we get everything finalized in a bit.
Unfortunately I agree with them...
All these committee meetings and determination to be "legal" will lead to failure of Black Frog. The old saw about "taking a knife to a gunfight" will apply.
Question: What will all the "It must be legal!!!!" people say when spammers start shutting//ddosing parts important down the Internet?
Will they be calling for the Black Frog network to be shut down...?
You'd better answer this question before doing any serious coding.
By keeping it legal we will
By keeping it legal we will get more members and be more effective. That is why Blue Frog was so effective that the spammers devoted so much effort to shut it down. I am not against vigilante action against spammers but any such action individuals take should be completely independent of Okopipi and done in an individual capacity.
There are already plenty of illegal/semi-legal actions being used to fight spammers. They are perfectly valid and useful but none of them are as effective as Blue Frog was.
I'd be happy to sign up to an illegal anti-spam group using similar methods to Blue Frog, and to use it alongside the legal version. But it is the legal version that will have the most impact. Okopipi should be legal and totally independent of anything legally dubious.
Keeping it legal
"Keeping it legal" may be good as a PR move but I don't think it will help in the fight against spam (which is the only thing I'm really interested in).
My two questions are still unanswered:
a) What will the "legal" people do when spammers start shutting down critical parts of the internet? Will they stand their ground or will they call for Black Frog to stop?
b) What will Black Frog do about captchas? They seem to defeat Black Frog's purpose.
[ http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Captcha ]
Infiltration
And they've got a point in there too that it wouldn't take a whole lot for a few of them to infiltrate the new frog community. Where is the validation going to come from that one of them has not added malicious code to the mix?
Let 'em attack
No I will not want it to stop. Let them attack. It only serves to draw attention to them. If they attack critical parts of the internet then people with far more power and computer knowledge will target them for retaliation. Attacking will ultimately be their downfall if they decide to go that route.
No one has an answer for that. This also posed a problem for bluefrog. Submitting opt outs to a website should not be the only attack we have in our arsenal. We should also report the spam to ISP's and the proper organizations that can shut the spammers down without having to attack. A successful Okopipi will not be solely based on submitting opt outs. That won't be enough.
Don't know if this is the right place....
why is it taking so long to develop this? Bluefrog was working and then it shut down. Can't someone ask them for the source code and run with that? I am getting piled up with spam and need some help.
I sort of agree
We should somehow get a running bluefrog (but have it be seporate from this project)... just something that would be hosted on a MAJOR server (like a google or yahoo or something that could handle HUGE loads and able to withstand a DOS attack) and first need to have a new way to encrypt the email lists to prevent them from getting emails (one way encryption should be used)